Love this podcast!! You guys are awesome. And the music?! LOVE IT!!! Thanks guys!

Good podcast but sometimes I have to keep hitting skip when football talk starts. And Jesus Christ. Just listened to the June 20th episode on the mushroom killer. In 20 Minutes there were four different ad breaks. I get it. You gotta pay bills. But that’s a bit excessive.

I’ve listened for years and tried to stick with TCG but honestly since Loren left and was replaced with Andy . . . I just can’t. Andy’s constant obnoxious jokes have driven me to leave this one behind. Half of every episode is filled with him just going off and trying to be funny. Far too much ridiculousness considering the very serious subject matter.

I just started listening a little over a month ago I binge while I work so I’m still on 2021 but I love your show I love the take you guys do and you make it a better listening experience with your stories and everything my I love the banter and how you have a different intro you guys sound like you’ve been friends since birth lol keep up the good work I also follow your other show strange and unexplained haven’t listened yet till I finish binging this one but can’t wait to ps I love the fake accents you do and how you always make me laugh

You guys WERE amazing once Lorne left I stuck with you and like Andy quite a bit. but you have now joined every other lazy podcast who play unintelligible audio.

Very well organized and great storylines. Definitely my favorite crime podcast, in-depth research. Love it!

Last episode was 220 making fun of the Korean people and the names was awful. Then Son joined an extreme Christian group “sounds about right” what? Dry mouth and the reading was enough for me. I never complain about commercials but I got all of them in Spanish From so-cal electric and Disney Just a waste of time and not funny

I’ve been binging for a few months now and finally signed on the Patreon train. I must say I was sure about the switch with Andy. However, I find myself laughing a lot. I consider myself a true crime lover and still learn new cases constantly from them. You won’t regret this podcast. Keep creepin’!

Hands down the best True Crime podcast ever. The theme song for the episode Lizzie Borden lives in my head rent free. I love how you guys are so laid back but know when to hit the serious button. P.S. True crime pine smells amaze balls.

I stumbled upon this podcast after randomly searching for the Cough Syrup Killer episode. No joke, the killer is actually my coworker’s step-brother. I hadn’t heard of this case until she told me about it and I was amazed how many podcasts had covered it. So, I gave your podcast a go and boy was I glad I did. You guys are amazingly entertaining. Plus, as a native North Carolinian who is currently broiling away in Texas, may I just say how refreshing it is to hear the word Appalachian pronounced correctly! It feels good to be connected to familiar accents again.

Absolutely loved the intro song. Great job Michael on writing and singing. And the episode story was well done too. Thanks for the entertainment.

I’ve been listening to these guys since I was 17 and I’m 24 now so whew and they have always been great. Very informative, super funny and have always made my day. Loved the show and the atmosphere the hosts create so much the moment I got a little disposable income I became a patron. It’s been such a pleasure to see the show grow and advance into what it is now and I absolutely can’t wait for more!

One star for making me spit out my coffee in public from uncontrollable laughter. Five starts for the creativity, humor, empathy, and great storytelling. The new guy is an awesome addition to the team.

He is so annoying and distracting.

They think they're funny, but it's terrible.

Show went down hill fast when Lorne left

I just found this show about a month ago and have obsessively been listening since. It’s the only one I will pay Patreon fees to listen. They add humor to help get through the tougher shows.

Miss the old podcast, too Much chatter now, hard to stay focused on the story.

I don’t know where they get their info but the episode I listened to was very wrong. How do I know? I’ve extensively researched because it’s my personal family history. I have first hand documents that disprove much of the episode. It was entertaining.. but fiction.

I’ve listened to this podcast for years, and love it. Lorne will be missed but Andy is doing a great job and his comments keep things light despite how dark the subject matter can be. You guys keep it up!

I miss Loren. When will he make an appearance. Or is he on another show

I’ve been a long time listener and I have to say it…I love Lorne, he’s truly fantastic and I was hesitant about the change in co-hosts, but this change has gone over well with me! The dynamic with Michael and Andy is absolutely amazing. They maintain the detail regarding the case but there is such natural banter along the way that gives it a bit of a boost. I really hope Lorne sticks with it and stays involved, I also can’t have more respect for the guy for bowing out the way he did and why. But what you guys have going is a game changer, for me at least. Creeper for life.

Only on 78, I started from the beginning. Love the twisted sense of humor! Please stop trying to say Nawlins 😂.

🫶🏻 nice, me likey

I listen to the show on Spotify and almost listen to every one! I love how y’all keep it light hearted and serious when you need too. I recommend this show to anyone who loves true crime and a good laugh. Love y’all keep it up

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 You guys rock! Love the songs and odd tangents😂

Can’t stand the guy. Going from Lorne who was very serious and informative to Andy it a very sharp difference in the show. I tried to get used to it but he’s insufferable

I love the show and try to give five stars often. You guys are well researched and make me laugh. Thank you!

Really enjoy the stories and listening to you guys. It was great with Lorne and we wish him the best with his other endeavors. Andy is truly hilarious and while it sometimes seems that he’s talking a lot because he’s new or a little nervous, y’all have great chemistry. The “birthdays in common with” thing seems silly but it’s been going on forever and that’s y’all’s thing so I get it. The research seems solid and thorough. Keep up the good work and thanks for covering lots of stories and cases that not many (if any) others have done. Overall great podcast. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was a 5 star review but don’t like the new guy so won’t be listening anymore

New guy is really annoying! He keeps interrupting with his dumb comments and it’s difficult to get into the story. Too much laughing too, which is kinda disrespectful to the victim . Sorry, I have to stop listening.

my mom has been listening to you guys for quite a bit now, and she’s a major freeloader so she wanted me to tell you that you guys rock!

I like the new guy so far 👍🏻

This podcast is great! Lots of research is put into each case both big and small. They respect the victims. I found the podcast from Killer Queens in November. I just joined patreon so I can keep creeping! Keep creeping ✌️

Guys! I happily found you with your mountain of content, will be joining Patron once I catch up. Wrapping up the end of your 1st year of COVID, can’t wait to hear how your booster hits you. I love the banter. It’s like one on one time with two friends who don’t let me talk. Much love ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

In love with this podcast!!!! Absolutely love the humor and story telling!! Keep the amazing work!!!❤️❤️

Will miss Loren! Looking forward to Michael and Andy.

Love this podcast

Love the banter and love the stories. Just can’t get enough!!!

The guy that says “you know what I’m saying” after every comment has got to go! Also no one cares about what celebrities share a birthday with the victim, such a weird thing to talk about for 3-5 mins

I join these guys every night (new listener - catching up on all the episodes). They are great and have great banter. Honestly, some of the side talk is just as interesting as the story they are sharing. Side note: omg ohmygaia - Wicked good kid ha (Bostonian) But seriously, I am so glad I tried it.

So glad I found you guys. I work 60-70 hours a week as a home health occupational therapist & this gives some break from my crazy but amazing job. IM GONNA KEEP CREEPING because I just signed up for Patreon & I’ve been binge listening from oldest and I’m only 1 year behind at Nov 2018! I’m getting there.

One of the better chit-chat true crime podcasts out there! I peruse most true crime podcasts but I stick with very few. This one is a keeper! I love the sidetracks and opinions, but even without that, at its core this is a very well researched podcast. These are (maybe former?) coworkers that discuss one story per episode, but the episodes are long and involved. It’s been so nice to listen to during quarantine because it feels like I’m listening to my own coworkers chat in the background and I love it! While a personal goal of quarantine was to look exactly the same after as I did before it started, due to these two I’ll be returning with more laugh lines. Luckily it’s worth it :)

I have been listening to you guys pretty much since year one. You both have a great mojo between you and I’m always laughing or curious one of my favorite true crime podcast of all time. Lauren and Michael I wish the best and keep it up!

I’m a proud freeloader!! I love listening. found this podcast a few months ago and have been working my way through from day one.

Sometimes listening to this podcast is the only part of my day where I crack a smile. Definitely one of my favorite podcasts without a doubt! Love the show - keep doing what you’re doing!

Let me start by saying this is my favorite true crime podcast. Lorne and Michael are great hosts and their chemistry is hilarious. Always bringing the best and weirdest cases. And they get through each episode with as much information, humor and perspective as possible. But one thing has been bugging me for awhile and I just had to get it out. Lorne always cuts Michael off in conversations. It’s every episode at least 2-3 times. I don’t know if it’s from editing or it just happens but when it does it grinds my gears. And on the other hand Michael is very patient and waits his turn to speak. I just had to get that out there.

This case is haunting. I’m glad you took it on. How many times have we done something so similar in our younger days? You’re with your friends and then suddenly, the nightmare begins.

The show has to much content I want more banter and songs

I’ve listened to a few podcasts, but this one right here has made its way into my daily listens. I was recommended this one because of the information and banter from my Girlfriend’s Mom, quoting my form of humor matches Micheals. She was right. Love this show, looking forward to setting up my Patreon account once I finish all the episodes. Only 3 left to go! Keep Creeping, and Oh My Gaia is the bomb.